Testing citation skills and overconfidence of AI chatbots

Mar 17, 2025

When you enter a query in traditional search engines, you get a list of results. They are possible answers to your question, and you decide what resources you want to trust. On the other hand, when you query via AI chatbot, you get a limited number of answers, as a sentence, that appear confident in the context.

For Columbia Journalism Review, Klaudia Jaźwińska and Aisvarya Chandrasekar tested this accuracy and confidence by using several chatbots to cite articles:

Overall, the chatbots often failed to retrieve the correct articles. Collectively, they provided incorrect answers to more than 60 percent of queries. Across different platforms, the level of inaccuracy varied, with Perplexity answering 37 percent of the queries incorrectly, while Grok 3 had a much higher error rate, answering 94 percent of the queries incorrectly.

So not great.

I am sure someone is working on improving that accuracy, but we’ll have to develop our own skills in separating truth from junk, just like we have with past online things. Going forward, maybe keep an eye out for the younger and older generations who tend to accept online things as automatic truth. Things could get dicey.

Become a member. Support an independent site. Get extra visualization goodness.

See What You Get

Favorites

Finding the New Age, for Your Age

You’ve probably heard the lines about how “40 is the new 30” or “30 is the new 20.” What is this based on? I tried to solve the problem using life expectancy data. Your age is the new age.

How the American Work Day Changed in 15 Years

The American Time Use Survey recently released results for 2018. That makes 15 years of data. What’s different? What’s the same?

Where Bars Outnumber Grocery Stores

A closer look at the age old question of where there are more bars than grocery stores, and vice versa.

The Stages of Relationships, Distributed

Everyone’s relationship timeline is a little different. This animation plays out real-life paths to marriage.