Visualization underneath the surface

Posted to Visualization  |  Nathan Yau

Moritz Stefaner of Well-formed data gives thought to propositional density as it pertains to visualization. There are two kinds. The first is surface propositions, which are straightforward statements about what we see. The second is deep propositions. These are statements that aren’t so straightforward, like how we feel while looking at a graphic.

Moritz uses the FedEx logo as a simple example. First, the surface proposition:

“The FedEx logo type is purple” and “The FedEx logo type is set in a sans-serif font” are propositions, and because they describe salient, perceptible properties of the design, they are referred to as surface proposi­tions.

Then there are deep propositions:

Now, the FedEx logo became famous for a perceptual trick: The white space between the E and the x cre ates an arrow. This arrow induces, by its semi otic read ing, a num ber of addi­tional associations and readings of the design: “FedEx is on the go”, “FedEx is forward-thinking”, etc. Note that these propositions, unlike the surface propositions, are much harder to enumerate as they depend on the meaning that the observer ascribes to the arrow.

So how does this pertain to visualization? Oftentimes work is judged by graphical perception alone – how well does it show the trend or does it properly represent outliers? That’s just the tip of the iceberg though. We have yet to look closely at what’s underneath.

Read the rest on Well-formed data. It’s interesting to think about, even if you disagree with the argument.

5 Comments

  • I seriously never ever noticed that arrow there before. huh

  • Me either, does that make it a success or a flop?

  • @tudza: I think it makes it subtle, and clever. Therefore, it’s a major success. It might even be art (though I’m not sure I’m willing to take it that far). There is this idea that the world must be simple or its a failure, and I disagree. Sometimes subtle touches make it much more interesting.

  • I never noticed it either. It is subtle, and clever I would say. I guess some would see it and others would overlook it, depending on how they look at it? (There must be some science behind this…)

  • I’ve been seeing that logo for a couple of decades without noticing the arrow. Glad I’m not the only one.

Favorites

Watching the growth of Walmart – now with 100% more Sam’s Club

The ever so popular Walmart growth map gets an update, and yes, it still looks like a wildfire. Sam’s Club follows soon after, although not nearly as vigorously.

This is an American Workday, By Occupation

I simulated a day for employed Americans to see when and where they work.

Pizza Place Geography

Most of the major pizza chains are within a 5-mile radius of where I live, so I have my pick, …

Real Chart Rules to Follow

There are rules—usually for specific chart types meant to be read in a specific way—that you shouldn’t break. When they are, everyone loses. This is that small handful.