Is an Animated Transition From a Scatter Plot to a Bar Graph Effective?

Statistical graphics are kind of stuck in a static funk where you create a plot in R, Excel, or whatever, and you can’t really interact with it. If you want another graphic, you manually create it. Hence, Jeffrey Heer and George G. Robertson investigated the benefits of using animation in statistical graphics.

Transition Challenges

They experimented with several kinds of animated transitions like sorting, filtering, visualization change, and scaling. In the case of visualization transitions (e.g. scatter plot to bar graph), the designer has to make sure each visual cue correctly transitions to the new symbol of comparison. If there’s an incorrect transition, someone using the tool could (and will) mistakenly perceive a non-existent correlation. Yuck.

Their Results

A tool called DynaVis was designed to experiment on 26 users. Enthusiasm and usability notes were positive while the most convincing of the results was probably the measure of memory. The comparison of static graphics to animated produced interesting results shown in this chart:

Results

The main thing to note here is that the error rate with static graphics (in blue) was way higher than for the animated graphics.

More Complexity

[W]e belive our results provide compelling evidence for the use of animated transitions in data graphics and that the presented design principles can be fruitfully applied in crafting additional effective animations.

This challenge of course gets even harder as you bring in more (complicated) data and more complex visualization techniques. What design considerations are there for a transition from one animated visualization to another animated visualization; or static to animated? I sense interesting answers ahead.

Favorites

Divorce Rates for Different Groups

We know when people usually get married. We know who never marries. Finally, it’s time to look at the other side: divorce and remarriage.

Top Brewery Road Trip, Routed Algorithmically

There are a lot of great craft breweries in the United States, but there is only so much time. This is the computed best way to get to the top rated breweries and how to maximize the beer tasting experience. Every journey begins with a single sip.

Best Data Visualization Projects of 2016

Here are my favorites for the year.

Real Chart Rules to Follow

There are rules—usually for specific chart types meant to be read in a specific way—that you shouldn’t break. When they are, everyone loses. This is that small handful.