A path for redesign as critique in visualization

Posted to Design  |  Tags:  |  Nathan Yau

Redesigning a visualization can be useful in teaching a point. Make a graphic better (or “better” depending on what angle you’re looking from) with a different layout and visual encodings. Perhaps the most well-known is Edward Tufte’s redesign from his book Visual Explanations in which he reworks a diagram used in decision-making for the space shuttle Challenger launch.

However, Fernanda Viégas and Martin Wattenberg explain why such redesigns can be problematic and offer a more useful approach.

At the same time, redesigns can be problematic. Tufte had one huge advantage over the creators of the diagrams used to make the space shuttle decision: he knew the answer to the question they were considering, and he knew exactly which variables mattered. His redesign makes an open-and-shut case at first glance. Stare a little longer, and you realize that the bulk of the visual effect rests on just one data point, the dramatic outlier at the upper left corner. Remove that, and the trend takes a far more muted form. Would it have convinced a stubborn politician to call off the launch?

Indeed, is it really a good idea to give so much weight to a single outlying data point? Clearly in the case of the Challenger it would have been. As a general rule, though: not always. One wonders… Had the launch gone off without incident, could someone with Tufte’s skill have created, from the same data, an equally convincing graphic about the wisdom of ignoring outliers?

Viégas and Wattenberg end with three rules of engagement: (1) maintain rigor, (2) respect the designer, and (3) respect the critic. Or, “WTF” doesn’t count as useful, don’t be a jerk to others, and don’t take criticism personally.

Worth reading the whole essay.

Favorites

Best Data Visualization Projects of 2016

Here are my favorites for the year.

Graphical perception – learn the fundamentals first

Before you dive into the advanced stuff – like just about everything in your life – you have to learn the fundamentals before you know when you can break the rules.

Causes of Death

There are many ways to die. Cancer. Infection. Mental. External. This is how different groups of people died over the past 10 years, visualized by age.

Where People Run in Major Cities

There are many exercise apps that allow you to keep track of your running, riding, and other activities. Record speed, …