Combatting the Obsession with New Tools

Posted to Software  |  Tags: ,  |  Nathan Yau

Michal Migurski thinks about finding the right job for the tool rather than the other way around:

Near the second half of most nerd debates, your likelihood of hearing the phrase “pick the right tool for the job” approaches 100% (cf. frameworks, rails, more rails, node, drupal, jquery, rails again). “Right tool for the job” is a conversation killer, because no shit. You shouldn’t be using the wrong tool. And yet, working in code is working in language (naming things is the second hard problem) so it’s equally in-bounds to debate the choice of job for the tool. “Right tool” assumes that the Job is a constant and the Tool is a variable, but this is an arbitrary choice and notably contradicted by our own research into the motivations of idealistic geeks.

Along the same lines, Frank Chimero on not trying any new tools for the year and how each represents someone’s perspective:

Everything that’s made has a bias, but simple implements—a hammer, a lever, a text editor—assume little and ask less. The tool doesn’t force the hand. But digital tools for information work are spookier. The tools can force the mind, since they have an ideological perspective baked into them. To best use the tool, you must think like the people who made it. This situation, at its best, is called learning. But more often than not, with my tools, it feels like the tail wagging the dog.

These approaches apply well to analysis and visualization. In the early goings especially, there tends to be an obsession with what tools to use. Which is best? Which is fastest? Which can handle the most data? Which makes everything beautiful? And yeah, it’s good to give these some thought in the beginning, but don’t get stuck asking so many questions or pondering so many scenarios that you never settle down and do actual work.

There’s always going to be a new application that promises to help you do something with your data. Work on this stuff long enough and you’ll find that you probably won’t need that new thing.

Favorites

Marrying Age

People get married at various ages, but there are definite trends that vary across demographic groups. What do these trends look like?

Reviving the Statistical Atlas of the United States with New Data

Due to budget cuts, there is no plan for an updated atlas. So I recreated the original 1870 Atlas using today’s publicly available data.

The Best Data Visualization Projects of 2011

I almost didn’t make a best-of list this year, but as I clicked through the year’s post, it was hard …

Real Chart Rules to Follow

There are rules—usually for specific chart types meant to be read in a specific way—that you shouldn’t break. When they are, everyone loses. This is that small handful.