Not so Hot Graphs in Academic Papers

Sep 3, 2007

Ribbon GraphKarl Broman has an amusing list of the top ten worst graphs found in academic papers.

One of them, very sadly, was actually from the Journal of the American Statistical Association, a very prominent statistical journal. It just goes to show that some have an eye for data, and others might have an eye for visualization, but one doesn’t necessarily lead to the other. Don’t forget to read the discussion on why the graphs are um, not so good, so that we can all learn from the mistakes of those before us.

My personal favorite is the 3-d ribbon graph, because it’s just so ugly. Why would anyone use that? Too many shades of gray mixing, too many lines crossing, too many dimensions. Brain overload.

I guess the graph was made in 1994, so I could cut the authors some slack….

No, they’re just bad. I was making way better graphs in Excel by that time for my seventh grade science fair project — What Cereal do Red Flour Beatles (Tribolium castaneum) Prefer?

Look what you’ve done Microsoft Excel. Apologize for what you’ve done this very minute.

Oh, and they preferred Cheerios and stayed away from the Grape Nuts.

Favorites

A Day in the Life of Americans

I wanted to see how daily patterns emerge at the individual level and how a person’s entire day plays out. So I simulated 1,000 of them.

Famous Movie Quotes as Charts

In celebration of their 100-year anniversary, the American Film Institute …

Shifting Incomes for American Jobs

For various occupations, the difference between the person who makes the most and the one who makes the least can be significant.

The Changing American Diet

See what we ate on an average day, for the past several decades.