Bias built in to crime prediction

Posted to Statistics  |  Tags: , ,  |  Nathan Yau

Predictive policing seems to be playing a bigger role in court decisions these days. People charged with crimes can be given a risk score based on priors and their background, which represents a fuzzy likelihood that they commit a crime again. ProPublica investigates the reliability of these scores, using data from Broward County, Flordia, between 2013 and 2014

The score proved remarkably unreliable in forecasting violent crime: Only 20 percent of the people predicted to commit violent crimes actually went on to do so.

When a full range of crimes were taken into account — including misdemeanors such as driving with an expired license — the algorithm was somewhat more accurate than a coin flip. Of those deemed likely to re-offend, 61 percent were arrested for any subsequent crimes within two years.

So tons of uncertainty.

Then, when you compare scores for blacks and whites, taking into account the types of crimes committed, there appeared to be a bias towards scoring blacks at higher risk. Troubling. I suspect this is related to the mentioned factors like employment and education.

But still, with so much uncertainty case-by-case, should these numbers — that I can only imagine appearing nearly concrete in the court room — even be part of the equation of an individual’s future?

More on the ProPublica analysis here.

Favorites

10 Best Data Visualization Projects of 2015

These are my picks for the best of 2015. As usual, they could easily appear in a different order on a different day, and there are projects not on the list that were also excellent.

Top Brewery Road Trip, Routed Algorithmically

There are a lot of great craft breweries in the United States, but there is only so much time. This is the computed best way to get to the top rated breweries and how to maximize the beer tasting experience. Every journey begins with a single sip.

Who is Older and Younger than You

Here’s a chart to show you how long you have until you start to feel your age.

Shifting Incomes for American Jobs

For various occupations, the difference between the person who makes the most and the one who makes the least can be significant.